Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts

Monday, 4 April 2016

Carl Sagan


I would not hesitate to say that he is one of the most spiritual and loving person I have ever seen. Yes, a scientist can be a spiritual person and be proud of it because his understanding about spirituality is neither narrow-minded nor any less than extremely profound depth. He was a man who will have your feel deep reverence and humongous respect.

For those who don't know him, he was an American astronomer, astrophysicist,a professor at Cornell, a science popularizer and an author. He was a founding member of the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry (formerly known as CSICOP - the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal). He has written hundreds of research papers and his work in astronomy is of very important significance. He initiated one of the most famous skeptical principles, "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence". And how can we forget Cosmos? His brilliant way of communication, soul-soothing voice and deeply humble nature, his sheer dedication towards work, his scientific understanding and inquisitiveness about nature makes him a complete package. There have been many brilliant scientists till now but very few touch the hearts of people- Carl Sagan is one of them and probably among the top of them.

His quotes are a fresh reading, very intriguing, profoundly written showcasing his exceptional skills. I am absolutely sure that a single article will never do justice to describe a man for whom the appreciation surpasses all the limits of English vocabulary. He time and again reminded us about the scarily large nature of our Universe but with added wisdom. He taught us to be a skeptic without losing wonder for the "vast and deeply humbling" Universe. I absolutely love this man and his smile.





If you want to know him, read this exceptional piece from him. When Voyager 1 spacecraft left from the planet to explore the solar system, engineers on Sagan's suggestion made it to turn back at take a photo of Earth and they got this-


 The absolute tiny dot is Earth. You probably need to look at it again to determine it. Now this surely can be a devastating picture completely redefining what we know about ourselves. It was the first time, somebody took a picture of the planet from this far. At this frightening picture Sagan wrote in his book Pale blue dot-

“Look again at that dot. That's here. That's home. That's us. On it everyone you love, everyone you know, everyone you ever heard of, every human being who ever was, lived out their lives. The aggregate of our joy and suffering, thousands of confident religions, ideologies, and economic doctrines, every hunter and forager, every hero and coward, every creator and destroyer of civilization, every king and peasant, every young couple in love, every mother and father, hopeful child, inventor and explorer, every teacher of morals, every corrupt politician, every "superstar," every "supreme leader," every saint and sinner in the history of our species lived there-on a mote of dust suspended in a sunbeam.

The Earth is a very small stage in a vast cosmic arena. Think of the endless cruelties visited by the inhabitants of one corner of this pixel on the scarcely distinguishable inhabitants of some other corner, how frequent their misunderstandings, how eager they are to kill one another, how fervent their hatreds. Think of the rivers of blood spilled by all those generals and emperors so that, in glory and triumph, they could become the momentary masters of a fraction of a dot.


Our posturings, our imagined self-importance, the delusion that we have some privileged position in the Universe, are challenged by this point of pale light. Our planet is a lonely speck in the great enveloping cosmic dark. In our obscurity, in all this vastness, there is no hint that help will come from elsewhere to save us from ourselves.


The Earth is the only world known so far to harbor life. There is nowhere else, at least in the near future, to which our species could migrate. Visit, yes. Settle, not yet. Like it or not, for the moment the Earth is where we make our stand.
It has been said that astronomy is a humbling and character-building experience. There is perhaps no better demonstration of the folly of human conceits than this distant image of our tiny world. To me, it underscores our responsibility to deal more kindly with one another, and to preserve and cherish the pale blue dot, the only home we've ever known.” 




Please please listen to this historic piece with added charisma of his voice as well!

Pale Blue dot

  • Here is Carl Sagan taking on religion!


“How is it that hardly any major religion has looked at science and concluded, “This is better than we thought! The Universe is much bigger than our prophets said, grander, more subtle, more elegant?” Instead they say, “No, no, no! My god is a little god, and I want him to stay that way.” A religion, old or new, that stressed the magnificence of the Universe as revealed by modern science might be able to draw forth reserves of reverence and awe hardly tapped by the conventional faiths.”

  • And Carl Sagan taking back on a very widely prejudiced thought about scientists being "dry" because they try to break things too much- 
“It is sometimes said that scientists are unromantic, that their passion to figure out robs the world of beauty and mystery. But is it not stirring to understand how the world actually works — that white light is made of colors, that color is the way we perceive the wavelengths of light, that transparent air reflects light, that in so doing it discriminates among the waves, and that the sky is blue for the same reason that the sunset is red? It does no harm to the romance of the sunset to know a little bit about it.” 

  • An excerpt taken from his one of the many essays-
There is a wide yawning black infinity. In every direction the extension is endless, the sensation of depth is overwhelming. And the darkness is immortal. Where light exists, it is pure, blazing, fierce; but light exists almost nowhere, and the blackness itself is also pure and blazing and fierce. But most of all, there is very nearly nothing in the dark; except for little bits here and there, often associated with the light, this infinite receptacle is empty.
This picture is strangely frightening. It should be familiar. It is our universe.
Even these stars, which seem so numerous, are, as sand, as dust, or less than dust, in the enormity of the space in which there is nothing. Nothing! We are not without empathetic terror when we open Pascal’s Pensées and read, “I am the great silent spaces between worlds.”



  • He was a noted skeptic. After an unbiased study, he concluded that there is not enough evidence about any alien activity on Earth, but still for the trash people are- 







  • And now it is time to look back at the pale blue dot quote- 

“Ann Druyan suggests an experiment: Look back again at the pale blue dot of the preceding chapter. Take a good long look at it. Stare at the dot for any length of time and then try to convince yourself that God created the whole Universe for one of the 10 million or so species of life that inhabit that speck of dust. Now take it a step further: Imagine that everything was made just for a single shade of that species, or gender, or ethnic or religious subdivision. If this doesn’t strike you as unlikely, pick another dot. Imagine it to be inhabited by a different form of intelligent life. They, too, cherish the notion of a God who has created everything for their benefit. How seriously do you take their claim?” 



  • He was a very beautiful thought generator.




  • Wish people understand this simple yet insightful message!




  • Well that's "true"!

  • Cosmic chemistry mixed with spiritual wisdom! My personal favourite



On religious terrorism and the importance of human




  • This one shows his humble nature hammering the rude skeptics!


  • And this is touching




Care for humanity!





  • And what to say anything else for this than simply amazing?!

  • With added benefits of well- refraining from pseudoscience, bad science, non-science and nonsense!






Here is a video of him describing astrology as bunk or bogus- His voice is simply touching!


He was indeed a great person, a reformer, brilliant scientist, a noted skeptic and a celebrity. His work for his students, the revolutionary Cosmos series and his amazing books will always be remembered. He is one of the most famous guardian of real science with deep insight and wisdom. 



This post is a second person-specific post. I have earlier written a similar style post for a brilliant philosopher Epicurus. Do check it out.



Share:

Friday, 22 January 2016

The Pseudo scientific Hinduism

Few friends of mine raised an objection towards my criticism of Islam, and not being equally fair for Christianity or well my own religion- Hinduism. Some even started sharing me the "islam love" photos that how people should treat Muslims "well".  I told them that criticizing a religion and hating a religion are two different things! Also, as some wise men correctly pointed out on twitter and later got shared with Dawkins, "If I hate cancer, it does not  mean I hate people with cancer!" I promised to them that I will do a piece on Hinduism too so here it is!

In the rising wave of secularist world, it is now the trend to market "science" in the religion to make it sell to the gullible.  Although there are also many books and lectures delivered to depict "science" in Christianity and Islam(Yeah its the Zakir Naik who will eat your head!), but in Hinduism it as at a completely different level.


A completely baseless opinion is established and then the all the 'facts' corresponding to the wishful thinking is first presented in a slow manner and suddenly a big leap is taken  just right at the crucial point and the guillible falls prey. It is a matter of strong base that we should stand up to scrutinize these facts when it is thundered down upon us. I find a lot of bad science arguments put in the favor of Hinduism which steals away the spiritual treasure it contains and make it a mechanical practice which seriously needs to be addressed.




Speed of Light is calculated in Vedas more accurately than Einstein did

This is literally the topic of an article. It takes special amount of guts to write, but it seems that the author don't give a damn about the modern science. The claim goes like this-

Ancient Vedic science “Nimisharda” is a phrase used in Indian languages of Sanskrit origin while referring to something that happens/moves instantly, similar to the ‘blink of an eye’. Nimisharda means half of a Nimesa, (Ardha is half).



In Sanskrit ‘Nimisha’ means ‘blink of an eye’ and Nimisharda implies within the blink of an eye. This phrase is commonly used to refer to instantaneous events.




Below is the mathematical calculations of a research done by S S De and P V Vartak on the speed of light calculated using the Rigvedic hymns and commentaries on them.



The fourth verse of the Rigvedic hymn 1:50 (50th hymn in book 1 of rigveda) is as follows:





तरणिर्विश्वदर्शतो जयोतिष्क्र्दसि सूर्य | विश्वमा भासिरोचनम |

taraNir vishvadarshato jyotishkrdasi surya | vishvamaa bhaasirochanam ||



which means:

“Swift and all beautiful art thou, O Surya (Surya=Sun), maker of the light, Illumining all the radiant realm.”



Commenting on this verse in his Rigvedic commentary, Sayana who was a minister in the court of Bukka of the great Vijayanagar Empire of Karnataka in South India (in early 14th century) says:

“ tatha ca smaryate yojananam. sahasre dve dve sate dve ca yojane ekena nimishardhena kramaman.” which means “It is remembered here that Sun (light) traverses 2,202 yojanas in half a nimisha”

NOTE: Nimisharda= half of a nimisha.



In the vedas Yojana is a unit of distance and Nimisha is a unit of time.

Unit of Time: Nimesa.

The Moksha dharma parva of Shanti Parva in Mahabharata describes Nimisha as follows: 15 Nimisha = 1 Kastha.


30 Kashta = 1 Kala,
30.3 Kala = 1 Muhurta,
30 Muhurtas = 1 Diva-Ratri (Day-Night),
We know Day-Night is 24 hours So we get 24 hours = 30 x 30.3 x 30 x 15 nimisha, in other words 409050 nimisha.

We know 1 hour = 60 x 60 = 3600 seconds.
So 24 hours = 24 x 3600 seconds = 409050 nimisha.
409050 nimesa = 86,400 seconds,
1 nimesa = 0.2112 seconds (This is a recursive decimal! Wink of an eye=.2112 seconds!).
½ nimesa = 0.1056 seconds.

Unit of Distance:
Yojana Yojana is defined in Chapter 6 of Book 1 of the ancient vedic text “Vishnu Purana” as follows:-
10 ParamAnus = 1 Parasúkshma,
10 Parasúkshmas = 1 Trasarenu,
10 Trasarenus = 1 Mahírajas (particle of dust),
10 Mahírajas= 1 Bálágra (hair’s point),
10 Bálágra = 1 Likhsha,
10 Likhsha= 1 Yuka,
10 Yukas = 1 Yavodara (heart of barley),
10 Yavodaras = 1 Yava (barley grain of middle size),
10 Yava = 1 Angula (1.89 cm or approx ¾ inch),
6 fingers = 1 Pada (the breadth of it),
2 Padas = 1 Vitasti (span),
2 Vitasti = 1 Hasta (cubit),
4 Hastas = a Dhanu,
1 Danda, or paurusa (a man’s height),
or 2 Nárikás = 6 feet,
2000 Dhanus = 1 Gavyuti (distance to which a cow’s call or lowing can be heard) = 12000 feet 4 Gavyutis = 1 Yojana = 9.09 miles

Calculation: So now we can calculate what is the value of the speed of light in modern units based on the value given as 2202 Yojanas in ½ Nimesa = 2202 x 9.09 miles per 0.1056 seconds = 20016.18 miles per 0.1056 seconds = 189547 miles per second !! 

First of all, they contradicted their own title. The speed of light is NOT mentioned in the Vedas but the attempt of indicating it is done by Sayana who was a courtier in 14th century while commenting on the RigVeda.. Then, the source of "nimisharda" is questionable. One myth takes value from ArthaShastra and another like this takes from Mahabharata. BOTH are NOT mathematical textbooks. Plus, the value of the unit "Nimesha" is questionable. I literally spent 3 hours straight trying to figure out the mathematical values they derived from the scratch and found out that it gives out contradicting values. Also the blink of an eye is not 0.2112 s, it is around 300 milliseconds but ofcourse this value which is calculated by "modern science" will not be used because the desired result will not be obtained. They just knew the final value and then inserted back the units to as to come to "close enough" answer. Also, the value of "Nimesha" arrived through the system of Vedic units, the value is 0.43 s. Funny, because they are not using the value which is mentioned in Vedas(and Wikipedia) to derive at the conclusion of what Vedas say!

Then again, why on earth would Sayana state a fact of such high importance in a so casual manner? The whole context of the phrase also is not presented. Plus, the verse is about Sun, and not light. And Science have to declare what are the methods which were used to come at the value, rather than just dabbling with figures.



                                        






Distance between Sun and Earth is Mentioned in “Hanuman Chalisa”- An Ancient Prayer


This is just a crazy one. Even Amitabh Bachchan tweeted about it once.

Two lines of Hindu Prayer ” Hanuman Chalisa” computes this distance with great simplicity.
“! जुग सहस्त्र योजन पर भानु, लील्यो ताहिमधुर फल जानू !”
This means that Sun (भानु) is at a distance of  Juug Sahastra Yojans (जुग सहस्त्र योजन- Distance Unit in Hindi)
According to following conversion practices that are in use as per Hindu Vedic Literature-
1 Juug = 12000
1 Sahastra= 1000
1 Yojan = 8 Miles
Thus
12000 X 1000 X 8 =  96,000,000  miles
1 mile = 1.6 kms
This further implies that distance is  96,000,000 * 1.6 kms = 153,600,000 Kms


 Before, my readers go further, I would like to go back and read the statement again. If you cannot point out the mitake, then either you are blind or didn't study Physics well. They multiplied time with distance to get distance! Jug is a unit of time(Also, the value 12000 is questionable because we don't know if it's Deva's years or human years) and Yojan is a unit of distance. They just multiplied them together because OH Why Not?

Also, funny that Yojana now became 8 miles. When they had to prove about the speed of light, Yojana was 9 miles.


Throwing coins in rivers


There is a tradition to throw coins in order to get your wish fullfilled. But may be these proponents have a rather brilliant wish- May people believe my nonsense.

The general reasoning given for this act is that it brings Good Luck. However, scientifically speaking, in the ancient times, most of the currency used was made of copper unlike the stainless steel coins of today. Copper is a vital metal very useful to the human body. Throwing coins in the river was one way our fore-fathers ensured we intake sufficient copper as part of the water as rivers were the only source of drinking water. Making it a custom ensured that all of us follow the practice.

Simple chemistry will tell you that Copper, like most metals undergo oxidation and it will form a protective layer over it so the coin won't let release copper for long time and it is a waste of- MONEY!. Also, I think drinking water in a copper vessel would be a lot useful method rather than making this stupid custom and wait for the lineages to realize the 'actual importance' of this years later!

Wait a second! They said river! River! River! River! How on Earth will throwing coins in the river which flows will make you intake the metal? Bad science as well as Bad logic Booooo........!

And this is just not it. They have all kinds of woo laden "Science" behind the namaskaram(acupressure for removing germs and also you can stay away from the germs of others ) , and by touching feet, how you can "transfer" the "energy" from one man to another(shaking hands gives germs but touching feet doesn't. Because "circuits" and "cosmic waves"), or whether kumkum is a sniper target for all the "peaceful energies" of the cosmos, and how we it turns out the plants and trees we worship like Tulsi and Peepal(Sorry, Neem bruh I feel for you!) are extremely important for their medicinal purposes(I thought ancient Hindus did it the other way around) and so on. Ayurveda propounders have practically convinced the public that everything which is natural is good for health and everything which is made through "western"(yeah in India we divide Science too!) science is bad and is a conspiracy to rob off the India from its wealth. In a lot of research conducted Ayurveda does not seems to be so effective anything more than a placebo. Yes, the herbs are of certain value and the credit seriously goes to the one who discovered them but Science actually works on them to tune up their qualities so that they are more beneficial. Although I don't see much harm in Ayurveda(and it is not as silly as Homeopathy) but blindly believing it will not take you anywhere. As I always point out, Hinduism is great, only if you care enough to understand it. It is vast and deep and magical. But I like to separate spiritual treasures like Upanishads and Geeta as Dharmic and  Vedanta literature to not club them up with some nonsense like this.

Since the New Age people are more popular with their crap like The Secret and quantum woo, you probably won't find these myths in the Internet you use. But, due to some past life "Karma" if you happen to come across things like Vyamanika Shastra(inspite of being proven wrong again and again) you are aware. 

No, I am not ridiculing any tradition nor undermining it. I consider that the tradition should be preserved through honest means and for it is, rather than being guided by magical thinking. One more thing, my dear friend has started a technical blog where he is writing about his projects and he will be sharing the Arduino cookbook by Jeremy Blum if you subscribe him here-  The Free Electron

Share:

Monday, 4 January 2016

Why I am against religion but why I don't think it should be removed completely.



We are living in a world of illusion, a dream. Whatever we do, see is through the goggles of our own self, our own perception and the worst part is that we cannot escape it. We do not know what it is like to see without any bias. Except you are a child, you will see everything with a bias of whether right or wrong, pleasant or unpleasant. This is how we have evolved and this is the thing by which we could come so far and survive ourselves. But this is also a cage. A closed room, however comfortable with air conditioners, video games, entertainment facilities and all that, is still a prison. You can enjoy it for sometime but at some point you will start getting lonely. You will slowly realize that in the illusion of this temporary happiness you have done nothing but captured yourself. This is what we have done. We are now a prisoner of our own thoughts, our own perception and it has become so close, and we have adjusted ourselves so much that we even cannot think of life being any other way than this. Our "mental self".If somebody forcefully lock you down, that's a different thing but here you have allowed your mind to takeover wilfully. You have locked yourself and swallowed down the key. Now your mind has conquered you too deep that you feel nothing wrong about it. You consider your mind as your own self. This is the biggest illusion and this is maya what ancient Indians talked about.

We as a mankind have built our life around this mental self. We do whatever it takes to make it happy thinking that "we" are getting happy. And we went to deeper and deeper mess. One more thing we invented to make this mental self more secure and happy was religion. It should be noted that the oldest religion- Hinduism was never a religion. It was a culture and philosophy. The ancient Indians just observed the life around them with great insight and sought to expand their views. India was a Godless country. Even the Vedas take an Agnostic position. They claimed they did not know who created this Universe or even whether a creator is required. Vedas only talk about the gods of nature. Their mythology included "forces" of nature. That's it. Ancient Egyptians also worshiped Ra who was nothing other than Sun. Then came the philosophies which were clearly atheistic(but not materialistic, you can call it pantheistic) which were filled with wisdom and tremendous insight. Even now people read them with great wonder. Upanishads were again great literature. Mystics who renounced their materialistic life and meditated heavily would sometimes come to consciousness and speak. Their disciples wrote it down and it became Upanishads. They are one of the most beautiful literature man ever wrote. Then ancient Indians started theology with a point to induce morality in the growing population. Then we had invasions and the invaders called the strange people living in India as "Hindus". There was no such thing as religion. It was a varied amount of culture with ethical values and great insight. The society was developed well ahead of their time. Invaders brought their own religion. And all the horseshit began.


The more and more we went away from nature, the more and more hallucinated we became. We started associating ourselves with thoughts. Religion was developed all around it. We did not do it because it was a correct path or anything, it was just that the founders of the religion tried to implement their own ideologies and nonsense to a larger number of people. Parents do that every time but only to their children. Some so called "prophets" tried to implement it on everybody they knew. They were just blind rules laid down in order to sustain the culture and people. One more purpose was to unite the people under one name. They were trying hard to protect people but they had no insight whatsoever. I like Christ. He was a true saint but I don't think he laid down Christianity as we know it. He just taught people to have faith in the God of Bible but laid down new and fresh teachings. His disciples wrote his account and formed Christianity. Then they inserted all his teachings back to Bible and thought that he was son of God. Surprisingly, there is even not a concrete amount of evidence apart from Bible that Jesus even existed at all and even the Shroud of Turin was a fake. Some Hindu fanatics believe that Jesus survived Crucifixion and lived the rest of his entire life in India. The modern Hindu fanatics have a habit, they point out every other religions or spiritual thought as having an origin in India itself. This story was made famous by Ashwin Sanghi. Some people believe him. If he is not viewed as a fiction writer, he is just one of the biggest woo-seller India ever produced after Deepak Chopra. He talks nothing but woo and his book "Krishna Key" is a guide to pseudoscience. It was a great book, though lol. Atleast Ashwin maintains his position as a fiction writer and he is amazing at that but Deepak is just outright charlatan. There is even a story that the story of Jesus is actually derived from the story of Krishna. Indians always dream about themselves being source of spirituality in the entire world never bothering to even try to know what that spirituality actually was. But, there are stories everywhere. The Zeitgist crap tells us that Jesus character is derived from the ancient Egyptian mythology. Ahh, lets not discuss theology anyway. There is nothing in it to be expert about. I am not making any claim but all these things are seriously beyond the grasp of my rational mind.


Then there is Islam. Let me say it very clearly, Islam is the worst thing mankind ever produced. And its the stupidest of all religions. I say that in your face, now do whatever you want. Contrary to what I may look, I am not Islamophobic or a Muslim hater. Criticizing Islam and hating Islam are two different things. But I am not even criticizing, I am just saying the truth. Quran has no morality in it whatsoever and contains terribly horrendous things. It practically teaches Muslims to follow bigotry and firmly believe that Islam is the truest religion and "fight the unbelievers". Few Islamic pseudo-scholars cherry pick some "goooood" verses from Quran and say "Hey look that's Islam". The only "good" things which Quran talks about is in fact so basic that even a 5 year old can tell you. Its morality is nothing more than what a 5 year old would have to say. And then there are so horrible things mentioned that it is not practical to describe in a single post. And Hadith is even more worse. Jesus Christ was a saint and in spite of Bible containing already many terrible things like slavery and killing(the level of which was raised by Quran) Jesus did a good job in raising the consciousness of the people. I loved his teachings. But he was heavily misinterpreted by his followers and the ignorants but Christianity really evolved to suit practical purposes. But when it comes to Mohammed, I don't think he was enlightened, I don't think he was even anywhere near being "spiritual". He was just a confused man and he had a hallucination while meditating in a cave that he met with an angel. He realised some spiritual truths which he never stressed upon. He was more interested in politics and he created the religion to expand the empire under one name. Quran clearly says that a Muslim is not allowed to marry a married woman but is free to do so to his women slave. Wait a minute, Islam teaches that you can have a slave, a women slave and you cannot marry a married women but you are free to have sex with your slaves even if they are married already and the sex has no limitation. And there are more than 1.6 billion people who consider Quran as the "perfect word of God". It is not that I am anti-Muslim. I like Muslim people just as much as anybody but I don't think their religion makes any sense or is relevant today. Its just that I hate cancer but I don't hate people with cancer. Islam and other religions were important for a certain period of time. Now, it isn't(clearly).


Hinduism although is very tolerant is not that great. The evil practices although not mentioned in the ancient texts were invented according to the situations. The invaders used to carry along the women of the warriors hence they invented Sati. And who don't know atrocious criminal activities like dowry and infanticide? Also the Bhakti Movement turned every philosophy and mythical figure to worship able objects without understanding the true nature behind it.


But religion has many advantages considering we KNOW that it is man made. We can go to mosque, bow down there and just feel the atmosphere. At least Muslims are rational enough to believe till now that their God is shapeless and heavily criticize idol worship. But idol worship has its own advantages and they are actually practical. For me, it does not matter whether you are worshiping a stone or idols made in somebody's image. They all are bullshit. But you cannot live your life satisfied with only materialistic gains, a time comes when a person says "enough" and he runs for these places. These places of worship have tremendous adavantages. Just go there and feel the calm atmosphere, that's it. Atheists don't like to go there. They believe they have figured it all out and does not feel like going around these places. Theists have their own "look around you, its so beautiful" logic and atheists have their science and rationality. For me, both are useless. One say there is a God, other say there is no God. Both do not know what is God. God or the True Self the one consciousness is beyond the plane of intellect and cannot be known through logical arguments. This "consciousness" was heavily misused by the New Agers to produce stupid theories like Law of Attraction and pseudo scientific explanations "vibrations", "universal consciousness", "ocean of consciousness" and all that. The core meaning behind it is actually something else but due to the constraint of the English language, they have to do it, its not their fault. But the fact is that most of the new age spiritual talkers don't know what they are talking about. And whenever you listen any spiritual talker talking about "quantum physics", its a high woo alert. Skeptics happily debunk it and spiritual talkers have nothing in defense to say. This is what happens when you mix spirituality with science. Science is a thought process and no process constrained by thought can discover what is beyond thoughts. Its not that they both are different things but they are different dimensions of life. There is no comparison between them, both are for experience, feeling and knowledge. That's all it's about. Religion tries to answer the questions which science had to. It talks about origin of Universe and life which are wrong. Spirituality has nothing to do with them, they are in zone of science. Spirituality teaches you to be in one with what there is. Without being biased and lays out ways to come out of the illusion of the mind matrix. Contrary to this, religion is actually build around this matrix thinking that that is is "soul". There is no such thing as soul. The brain produces the mind. Your "self" is nothing but a bag of chemicals. After death it will vanish and only the consciousness will remain which is eternal. Which is "neither born, nor dies". At low level of consciousness person thinks that he is body. But body always changes, something which changes cannot be "me". Then at somewhat higher level he thinks that self is mind. But on a close observation you will find that mind is not stationary, it changes according to circumstances. Then at even higher level, one starts detaching oneself from mind and this is where he reaches the awakened state where he realises everything is just One whole separated through illusion of space and time.


Atheists discard religion. This is also wrong. Everything is for a certain experience and everything is necessary. It brings hope between people, it's just that religion needs to be more flexible and open to evolution according to needs. Bible, Vedas, Upanishads will come and go. You will remain, you have to go through the infinite journey of life in different different forms and body. Its futile to stick to them. They are not any scientific books nor do they accurately answer about the origins of the worlds.I think anyone is entitles to believe whatever they like to in their own personal walls but what literally concerns me is that they put their blind faith in some age old religious books which they call "scriptures" which have been proven wrong again and again, written by stone age people out of their ignorance and being repeatedly proven as pack of lies. But instead of throwing away these books for the trash they are, they continue to accept it. Then they turn paranoid and disregard anything against it to be "conspiracies" to turn down their culture and think it is a "test", And they explain the obvious contradictions with some pseudo-logic and nonsense and easily get away with it and attempt to explain ambiguous verses as scientific facts. "Science in Vedas", "Science in Quran", "Science in Bible" when deeply investigated have been proven wrong again and again yet people blindly follow them as the highest authority and build their lifestyle around them.Vedas are pointing towards the sky but you are just holding the fingers. You have hold the finger too tight and you are not looking to what that finger actually points to.


Completely removing religion is like throwing away something just because it was not properly practiced. Religion only tells wrong stories about the real concepts. Just the explanations are wrong, but the concepts are right. Completely removing religion will be of no use. Its the religion which motivates man to search beyond without the power of science. It just that people need to know that they themselves invent it. I am against religion but I am not against religiousness. 
Share:

Wednesday, 11 November 2015

Hindu arguments against God

Hinduism is not only a religion, it's a philosophy, Supreme Court have already declared it to be a way of life, and not religion. We have freedom to choose our own God- whether a tree, monkey, or anything. This is a secular worldview in itself. You can see Hindu practices being immensely different at two places at the same time. This is its beauty, this is its color.

The Samkhya philosophy as quoted in Wikipedia, they are not my own thought but deserves to be mentioned. 

"Mimamsas argued that there was no need to postulate a maker for the world, just as there was no need for an author to compose the Vedas or a God to validate the rituals. They further thought that the Gods named in the Vedas had no physical existence apart from the mantras that speak their names. In this regard, the power of the mantras was what was seen as the power of Gods. Mimamsas reasoned that an incorporeal God could not author the Vedas, for he would not have the organs of speech to utter words. An embodied God could not author the Vedas either because such a God would be subject to the natural limitations of sensory knowledge and therefore, would not be able to produce supernatural revelations like the Vedas.
Samkhya gave the following arguments against the idea of an eternal, self-caused, creator God:
  • If the existence of karma is assumed, the proposition of God as a moral governor of the universe is unnecessary. For, if God enforces the consequences of actions then he can do so without karma. If however, he is assumed to be within the law of karma, then karma itself would be the giver of consequences and there would be no need of a God.
  • Even if karma is denied, God still cannot be the enforcer of consequences. Because the motives of an enforcer God would be either egoistic or altruistic. Now, God's motives cannot be assumed to be altruistic because an altruistic God would not create a world so full of suffering. If his motives are assumed to be egoistic, then God must be thought to have desire, as agency or authority cannot be established in the absence of desire. However, assuming that God has desire would contradict God's eternal freedom which necessitates no compulsion in actions. Moreover, desire, according to Samkhya, is an attribute of prakriti and cannot be thought to grow in God. The testimony of the Vedas, according to Samkhya, also confirms this notion.
  • Despite arguments to the contrary, if God is still assumed to contain unfulfilled desires, this would cause him to suffer pain and other similar human experiences. Such a worldly God would be no better than Samkhya's notion of higher self.
  • Furthermore, there is no proof of the existence of God. He is not the object of perception, there exists no general proposition that can prove him by inference and the testimony of the Vedas speak of prakriti as the origin of the world, not God.

Therefore, Samkhya maintained that the various cosmological, ontological and teleological arguments could not prove God." 


Share:

Sunday, 8 November 2015

What spirituality is all about- Lesson 1 Giving up the Binary Logic

It is all about mind-body dualism. That you are not this body. You are just experiencing it and not -it. But that does not immediately lead to soul. There are a number of differences between Religion and Spirituality and it is that we don't do stuff in order to "please" some deity who created us. We, in fact don't feel like the creator of the Universe to be like person. In fact according to Osho, "theology is all such nonsense".. many philosophers including spiritual leaders have argued that the humans draw their Gods as humans, tribals have tribal God, Negros have a negro God, Japanese have Japanese looking Gods. This is not plausible and indicates there is no absolute truth about Gods which is conceivable.

Wait, how can be you spiritual without believing in God?

Because there is more evidence to spirits, sacred geometry, etc than a religious God. If you make such an argument you conclude that spirituality arises from God but the fact is God in himself is spiritual and not physical. We, in our current sense of science understanding know that the source is something non physical. Matter is just an illusion and almost 99% of everything is actually -nothing. Stuff is coming from non-stuff. Consciousness is not physical. Hence we know source is not in any shape or size- so to say that God created Man in his own image is absurd. This is a sense of narcissism. "My God who created the entire Universe looks like me."


  Even if I agree that spirituality cannot happen without a faith in a religious God- then I will ask which God? Whether Abrahamic? Allah? Jesus? or Krishna or Zeus or Zoarastrian God? Which God? If I am born in India, I will believe in Krishna and source my spirituality from him, if I am born in Greek, I will derive my spirituality from Zeus, If I am a Muslim I will derive my spirituality from Allah. So, the source is irrelevant, but what everything has in common is the same thing- spirituality. In fact, "Everybody is an atheist" according to Richard Dawkins. Let me tell you religious Gods in a nutshell- GODS- Invisible, inaudible and imperceptible creatures who created this entire Universe to have a relationship with  creatures residing in absolute tiny tiniest parts of it specifically with one species- Luckily us. They spent so much time- 10 billion years to build this Universe, intrinsically placing each and each Galaxy in order and of perfect size and shape, exploding billions and billions of stars, and then to create an absolute tiny blue dot in the entire cosmos. And then after creating it, still waited for 4 more billion years before realizing that the true test of spirits is to make them a body in his own image and after 14 billion years of perfect creation and world JUST for humans, to test the creatures in order to provide ETERNITY of happiness or torture have given mere 100 years of life with a truly skeptic mind and ever growing thrust to know things and on the basis of their faith for bad evidence. In order to "help" humanity achieve heaven , they mouthed morals to primates, yet had none themselves. Who pledged vengeance upon crimes yet committed the all. Who swore forgiveness yet created Hell, who promised mercy yet sired Satan and allows Satan to live but decides to mercilessly kill and torture all those who gets carried away from him without providing a clear guidance. Who vowed to spread love yet sold us slavery. Who preached peace yet promoted genocide. Who told "Thou shalt not kill" but relevant to be applied only to your own tribe.

Realised the dilemma? We all are atheists to every God other than our religion, some people just go one God further, according to Dawkins. Now being Atheist should not mean materialism. Materialism is now not only old but is highly irrelevant and non-senseical. The "material" which we are made up of has absolute no reason to stay in their place as what we perceive to be. Quantum particles are non-local and we cannot determine their energy or position at the same time. Let me share with you some facts -

The enzymes which we are made of- chances of happening and being arranged in that level of sequence, according to Harvard University Maths professor is 10 raised to 40,000! That's more than the number of atoms we are made up of. So, if we think that it was all an accident, than the probability of success itself happens outside the total possibilities with the atoms. Plus the fact, that the Universe does not comprise of only organic matter leave the chances to be even less. So the probability is zero, not closed to zero, but just absurd. Scientists are discussing about it, physicists are discussing about this. But Materialists will just jump into the conversation and would overwhelmingly burden us with their extraordinarily logical and apprehension skills and can and WILL just convincingly conclude that "this" kind of "accidents" can occur. Now, the basic problem with this so overwhelmingly ignorant and highly biased attitude of saying that a printing press exploded into a dictionary, is that we don't see these kind of stuff happening in our daily lives. A universe which is in order just merely through accident should constitute of components which arrange themselves through accident and explosion. But we clearly see that this is not the truth. No amount of explosion in Earth will make things in order. Reality is more absurd than our wildest imagination of so thin possibilities of order within chaos. Clearly there is something much more than this concept. There are two theories which tries to low down our awe and a non-belief in materialism, i.e the theories which materialists use are-

1) There are Multi-verses. Please note that this theory is different from parallel Universes. Parallel Universes(which is slightly less difficult to believe but still not plausible enough to explain our observations) deals with different Universes which are equally orderly but the events are different. For example, in a different Universe YOU are probably not reading this post. But YOU are still there. And the Sun, the moon and everything which is required to constitute your existence is there. Only change is the consequence of the Universe, but the Universe remains still the same. That is why the term "parallel" and not "different". Multiverses says that there is a "Universe ejector" which ejects billions and billions of Universes and we are just in one of them statistically existing to be able to suit us. Now, this attitude of the argumentor shows that he has no absolute understandings of science and views everything in just abstract form. That every development and progress and hard work is just a joke and has no meaning and sense in a remote form. This only seem to logically explain things. That there are infinite number of Universes having different physical constants and we are one of them which has the elements supporting our life. Problem? The Universe ejector itself needs to be fine tuned! To create different Universes with different physical constants- for example one Universe to create which has the speed of light as 3.1 x 10^8, that universe is to be tuned to be able to produce distinct Universes otherwise both of them will collapse into one. There is no argument in return to that.

2) Universe is infinite and has different components for supporting different existences- This argument has basically come after realizing that the above argument is not sufficient. And also that there is not one factor for us, but there are numerous factors. ALL(I repeat, all) physical constants if disturbed in a order of 1 in 10^120, all forms of life could not exist. Realize the number, and this is not just for one, but all the constants. Plancks constant, Gravitation constant, Speed of light, Speed of sound, and hundreds of them. If even if one of them are disturbed in the order of 1 in 10 to the power of FREAKING 120, we could not exist. To say that this is just an accident is not sensible and is not logical to begin with. This fact can be confirmed with any theoritical physicist if you don't trust my knowledge. This is why almost all physicists are now increasingly becoming interested in the supernatural, or life after death, consciousness, etc. Even doctors. Which leads to numerous experiments on death and observations and studes on consciousness and spiritual healing, we will discuss them in later posts.

For now debunking the argument. Universe is infinite and in its infinite sphere of existence, it has different laws and we are in one of the region. In short, Universal constants are not not universal. If we accept this, even then our observations are not coinciding. If we slice our matters and explore the quantum mechanics, they are so nasty that they just ridicule our mechanics in our face. Projectile motion, gravitational force makes absolute no sense in the quantum world. The laws are completely different. So the particles we are made of, do not follow the law we do. Wait what? The "stuff" which we are made of does not follow the laws which we do. So, in the same region of Universe, the laws are different for different scales of world. Needless to also say, the region is highly in order and we have no connection to relate the two world. No connection at all. In this reality, argumenting such non-sensical statements is just absurd is not coming from a scientific mind. These minds are highly biased towards thinking stuff which they want to think and believe. This is just running from reality and turns down our desire to know more and more. Just like what religions do.

While religions try to put God in everything, Materialists try to remove God from everything. To think that same of region of Universe with the same set of law determining constants behave differently on different scales is not valid and the arguments put forward to support that reason should not be allowed.  What these people do not realise that they are practicing "blind" faith. Things like Multiple Universes are also based on blind faith and it can never be proven or the claim can never be measured. Just because it is ssuiting your style has no refernce to reality. Your argument is equally true as to the argument of a Christian that an all loving God created this world. You both are on the same pedestal- accept it.

So there in fact is something which we do not know- we still don't find any reason for evolution and why plants grow that why and all other stuff. We are told that "there is no reason to evolution" and that things just work that way is an attempt to suppress our mind so that we can stay and behave in their regions and sphere of belief. We will discuss the theory of evolution, theory of mechanics in later posts. Not that I don't believe in evolution, but the fact that everything just happened to be lucky? Sorry but no. Evolution did happen, but it could not happen in such a perfect (yet contradictory to our numerous predictions which should have been met) yet imperfect way. That, there is no fixed pattern in it, we could not even find what living conditions are required to actually develop even a bacteria. Evolution- what's true and what's being told to be true, we will see in detail later.



So, NOW.. we are summed up in two types of people- one who puts God in everthing and one who removes God from everything. This kind of bipolar debates are not leading us anywhere, that is a fact and our observation. It can also be true that some of the readers also will not being able to give up their bipolar belief. Wait, wither their can be a God or there is no God... what you are even talking about? That my friend, is where we enter spirituality. The purpose of this post, is to first remove this "binary" thinking pattern that where there IS something or there IS no such thing everywhere. We have to give up this "Either 0 or 1" thinking which we developed for computers and not ourselves. This "true" or "false" is the reason of chaos. "My religion is true, yours is not" , or "Everything is an accident, but certainly the order can be explained" . In Hindu philosophy, there is a teaching.. that a thing can not only be just "true" or false". A thing can be either "True", "False", "Both true or false", "Neither true nor false". And these are perfectly logical statements. We are doing it everyday, we are staying together even following different religions, our worship pattern can be different but we can still eat together. We create a diplomatic pattern in every belief or moral values in order to derive maximum pleasure for ourselves. We just have to expand our horizons. Expanding thinking is not needed, we are already that intelligent, we just have to expand our horizons and applications where we apply the thinking patterns. That's it. We have to develop more "levels" in our logical thinking than just binary. Kindly wait now for me to explain further, but the first step here is to give up binary thinking.

Thank You! In later posts, we will see about Vedanta, Vedas and other texts(without being biased about any God. Fact is, there are no much books which talks about God apart from Him "ordering" the entire humanity). Death, NDE's, sacred geometry, Evolution which fit with facts, Consciousness, ethics beyond religion and Biocentricism. I have little reach over Buddhism so anyone wanting to study about it should refer appropriate materials. Till then you can refer these videos-

https://www.youtube.com/user/TheSpiritScience

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K2KY6jmIzBQ(Science vs Spirituality)

and other spiritual talkers like Sadhguru, Osho, and numerous others. Also, materials like works of Swami Vikenanda, Bhagwad Geeta and books of Osho and Dalai Lama.


Share:

Featured post

Philosophers I love- Lao Tzu

You cannot discuss Chinese literature without discussing Lao Tzu. A great philosopher and founder of Taoism, one of the important tradition ...